Friday, April 21, 2017

Jason in the Forest

There is one passage from the chapter "Knife Grinder" that really stands out to me as an important moment in Jason's coming of age. He has just run away from the other boys, who were playing war, because he knew that if they saw him they would gang up on him. He escapes to the woods and is finally alone to reflect on himself.
Picked-on kids act invisible to reduce the chances of being noticed and picked on. Stammerers act invisible to reduce the chances of being made to say something we can't. Kids whose parents argue act invisible in case we trigger another skirmish. The Triple Invisible Boy, that's Jason Taylor. Even I don't see the real Jason Taylor much these days, 'cept when we're writing a poem, or occasionally in a mirror, or just before sleep. But he comes out in the woods. (233-234)
This is the most directly that Jason ever talks about the way he acts differently from his true stuff because of those around him. He seems to think of this as an undesirable thing, but doesn't seem about to do anything about it. However, facing the problem himself instead of just being told it is a problem by Eva van Outryve de Crommelynck.  Jason certainly recognizes that he has a true self that he hides from the outside world: the Jason Taylor who writes poems and speaks in long poetic phrases.  This acknowledgement of the problem is the first step towards its solution.

Also in this passage, Jason mentions that his true self comes out in the woods, and in that situation it is more than just a fleeting glimpse of the true Jason Taylor.  I think this can be seen in a slight shift in the narrative voice following this passage.  In some cases, his phrases even rhyme, "First every kid labels me as a tragic case, now half the teachers'll think I'm a waste of space" (235).  He also gets much more philosophical, as can be seen when he encounters a bird.

A bird so near it might have perched on the curl of my ear musicked a flute in a jar.  I quivered to own such an unownable thing.  If I could've climbed into that moment, that jar, and never ever left, I would've done.  But my squatting calves were aching, so I moved.  The unownable bird took fright and vanished down its tunnel of twigs and nows. (234)
First of all, this passage starts with another lyrical, rhyming (near, ear) sentence.  Then, the real Jason Taylor, alone in the woods, contemplates the fleetingness of time and wishes to preserve the purity of his moment with the bird forever.  Although he is talking to the narrator, not friend or family member, I think that this shows how much more at peace the true Jason is, the Jason who doesn't have to worry about what other people think.

Monday, April 3, 2017

Sylvie

For me, one of the most memorable scenes in Housekeeping was when Sylvie walked out onto the railroad bridge for the first time.  This act, in my opinion, reveals more about her character than any description that Ruth has given us.  Because Ruth and Lucille are by the lake and spot her by chance, we learn something about how she spends her days.  From the way Sylvie speaks to Ruth and Lucille about it, this very dangerous act of walking out onto a railroad bridge is nothing special in her eyes.
    "I had no idea it was so late!" she called as we walked towards her. "I though it would be an hour or so until school was out."
    "School isn't out," Lucille said.
    "Well I was right after all, then.  The 1:35 just went through a little while ago so it must be pretty early still." (81-82)
He tone is very relaxed and matter of fact, as if she just expects the girls to be totally ok with what she just did; Sylvie herself is certainly unfazed by the danger.  However, it is not that she is suicidal or deliberately putting herself at risk: Sylvie knows the train schedules by heart and makes sure that she will not be on the bridge at the same time as a train.  That being said, Sylvie still does take this risk, and does not seem to give too much thought to the consequences of her actions.  This becomes apparent when Lucille asks why she would do such a thing.
    "What was it like?" Lucille asked.  Her voice was small and flat and tensely composed.
    Sylvie shrugged and laughed. "Cold. Windy."
    Lucille said, "You did it just to see what it was like?"
    "I suppose so."
    "What if you fell in?"
    "Oh," Sylvie said, "I was pretty careful."
    "If you fell in, everyone would think you did it on purpose," Lucille said. "Even us."
    Sylvie reflected a moment.  "I suppose that's true." She glanced down at Lucille's face.  "I didn't mean to upset you." (82)
Sylvie doesn't give the danger much thought, simply saying that she was careful.  She also is unable to explain to Lucille a good reason for taking this risk.  However, I for one believe Sylvie completely when she says that she didn't mean to upset the girls.  She is not used to being responsible for others, and seems to be considering for the first time what would have happened if she had slipped and fallen in.  Is Sylvie crazy for behaving this way?  Do actions like this make her unfit to be the guardian of Ruth and Lucille?  Lucille certainly seems to think so...